Acrylic Baths vs. Traditional Bathtubs: Which is Right for You?

Choosing the right bathtub is a crucial decision in any bathroom remodel. With so many options available, it can be tough to determine which material best suits your needs and preferences. This blog post will compare acrylic baths with traditional tub materials, such as cast iron, steel, and fiberglass. We’ll review each type’s pros and cons to help you choose one that fits your style, price, and bathroom needs.

Acrylic Baths

Acrylic bathtubs have gained favor among homeowners in all states without exception due to their versatility, affordability, and wide range of design options. Produced from durable plastic, they’re lightweight and can be manufactured in a mixture of shapes and sizes, offering everlasting potential for customization.

When considering a bath OKC remodel, homeowners often find that acrylic baths provide an exceptional balance of durability and aesthetic appeal. Here are some key points to consider:

Pros:

• Feeling warm: Acrylic keeps heat in, so you can enjoy a comfortable bath.
• Resistant to Chipping and Cracking: More forgiving than other materials, making it durable and long-lasting.

Cons:

• Prone to Scratches: Although durable, acrylic can scratch more easily than harder materials like cast iron or steel.
• May Discolor Over Time: With prolonged use and exposure to certain chemicals, the color of an acrylic bath may fade or slightly change.

Photo by ObsidianArt from Freepik

Cast Iron Bathtubs

Cast iron bathtubs are known for their classic, timeless appeal. These heavy-duty tubs are coated with a layer of enamel, providing a smooth, glossy finish that encourages a more prolonged lifespan.

Pros:

• Extremely Durable: Can withstand heavy use and maintain its appearance over time.
• Excellent Heat Retention: Keeps water warm for extended periods, improving the bathing experience.

Cons:

• Very Heavy: Requires a reinforced floor and professional installation, increasing the complexity and cost of installation.
• Expensive: Generally more costly than other bathtub types, both in terms of initial purchase and installation.

Photo by 1138irinasaan from Freepik

Steel Bathtubs

Steel bathtubs, typically coated with enamel, offer a sleek, modern look and are popular with numerous homeowners. There are several reasons why.

Pros:

• Durable: Not easily chipped or cracked, thereby increasing shelf life (or bath life).
• Affordable: Generally less expensive than cast iron tubs, while retaining the durability aspect.
• Lightweight: Easier to install than cast iron, reducing labor costs.

Cons:

• Poor Heat Retention: Does not keep water warm for as long as cast iron or acrylic tubs.
• Prone to Rust: If the enamel coating is damaged, the underlying steel can rust over time.

Photo by Studioworkstock from Freepik

Fiberglass Bathtubs

Fiberglass bathtubs are another prevalent option among homeowners. These tubs are produced from layers of fiberglass-reinforced plastic and offer multiple benefits.

Pros:

• Inexpensive: One of the most affordable bathtub options available.
• Lightweight: Easy to install and maneuver, making it a cost-effective choice.
• Variety of Designs: Available in varied shapes and sizes to fit different bathroom styles and arrangments.

Cons:

• Less Durable: More prone to scratching, cracking, and fading over time than steel or cast iron.
• Lower Heat Retention: Does not maintain water temperature as well as acrylic or cast iron tubs.

Photo by Phanuwatnandee from Freepik

Comparison at a Glance

To help you make a decision, here is a comparison of the key features of each type of bathtub material. 

How to Make the Right Choice

When choosing between acrylic and traditional bathtubs like the examples we’ve outlined in this article, consider the following factors:

• Budget: If cost is the primary consideration, fiberglass and steel bathtubs offer more affordable options. Acrylic baths provide a middle ground with moderate pricing and excellent design flexibility.
• Durability: For long-lasting performance, cast iron and steel bathtubs are the top choices. Acrylic baths offer good durability with the added benefit of being more forgiving to minor impacts.
• Aesthetic Appeal: If you’re looking for a luxurious and classic look, cast iron bathtubs are unmatched. However, acrylic baths offer a wide range of design options to fit modern and traditional setups.
• Ease of Installation: Acrylic and fiberglass bathtubs are the easiest to install, making them ideal for DIY projects or quick remodels. Cast iron and steel tubs may require professional installation due to their weight and complexity.
• Comfort: Acrylic and cast iron tubs are the best options for warm and comfortable bathing. Steel and fiberglass tubs may not retain heat as well, affecting the overall experience.

Bottom Line

Choosing the right bathtub material depends on your needs, preferences, and budget. By carefully considering the pros and cons of each material, you can make an informed decision that improves your bathroom’s functionality and aesthetic appeal.